Puzzles and Photocopies: Challenging “Unreadable” Financial Reports

The November 18, 2025, meeting was a study in contrasts: a significant win for the physical safety of our seniors, followed by a total breakdown in the transparency of our fiscal records.

Progress at the Senior Center

I began my comments on a positive note, thanking the Board for taking action on the Senior Center flooring. After months of advocacy and reports of seniors falling, it is a relief to see this issue finally being addressed. Our seniors deserve a building that is safe and well-maintained, and I am glad to see that message was heard.

The “Photocopy” Problem

The bulk of my testimony, however, focused on the Approval of Accounts. Because the Finance/Audit Committee was sidelined this month by the ongoing audit, I was curious if anyone had actually looked at the 141-page budget report. What I found was baffling:

  • Scanned Cash: The public documents included scanned images of physical $5, $10, and $20 bills. It’s an odd choice for a government document and raises immediate questions about professional record-keeping.
  • The “Puzzle” Format: The General Ledger report arrived as a series of 22-page “slices”—left, middle, and right sides of a single table. To read one line of data, you would essentially have to tape three pages together.
  • The Tax Gap: Our delinquent tax reports currently show only a total balance. I urged the Board to break this down by tax type and age (30/60/90 days) so the public can understand the true state of our collections.

The Board Responds

I was encouraged to hear Supervisor Cullers and Henry echo my frustrations. Supervisor Cullers noted that she personally found the format difficult to navigate, stating, “As much as I like puzzles, I didn’t like this one.” Even more importantly, the Board acknowledged that:

  1. The reports are not currently “user-friendly.”
  2. Moving away from rigid PDFs to a more flexible format is a necessary “long-term fix.”
  3. They will carve out extra time at the December Finance/Audit Committee meeting specifically to address these reporting problems.

Final Thought

Transparency isn’t just about dumping 141 pages of scans onto a website; it’s about providing data that the public and the Board can actually use to make decisions. When reports are fragmented and physical cash is being scanned into the ledger, it suggests a system that is struggling to keep up with modern standards. I’ll be at that December committee meeting to ensure the “puzzles” are replaced with clear, searchable data.


Watch the Discussion

  • 0:08 – Thanking the Board for fixing the Senior Center floors.
  • 0:25 – Raising the issue of scanned currency in public records.
  • 1:12 – Describing the “left, middle, and right” split-page table format.
  • 2:33 – Supervisor Cullers admitting the report format is a “puzzle” she didn’t like.
  • 3:53 – The Board agreeing to address reporting formats in December.
WCBOS Nov 18, 2025 Transparency Takes Work

Discover more from Lewis Moten

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading